Distillers may be celebrating a new ruling by the EU's court, which has decreed that alcohol-free drinks cannot be marketed under the name 'gin'.
The Criteria Defines a True Gin?
According to the judicial ruling, only alcoholic beverages based on ethyl alcohol, flavored with juniper berries, and boasting a minimum alcohol content of thirty-seven point five percent by volume may legally be labeled gin.
Legal Dispute Leading to the Ruling
This case was brought by a German organization focused on combating unethical business practices, that challenged a firm selling a drink called 'Virgin Gin Alkoholfrei'.
The accused business argued in legal proceedings that the name obviously signaled it was a alcohol-free beverage. A national court had previously sided with this view, stating that the labeling removed any potential of deceiving customers and posed questions about whether EU spirits regulations infringed upon the freedom to conduct business under the European Union's fundamental rights.
Court's Definitive Stance
Nonetheless, the European judges reinforced existing legislation, declaring that the term 'non-alcoholic gin' is expressly prohibited. The court emphasized that adding the words 'non-alcoholic' alongside the protected term 'gin' does not change this prohibition.
Even though the legal name ‘gin’ is accompanied by the term ‘non-alcoholic’ is irrelevant,” the court said.
Wider Consequences and Context
This 2019 EU regulation underlines that such rules are designed to protect buyers, prevent misleading marketing, guarantee fair competition, and protect the global standing of the EU's spirit drinks.
Yet, this ruling might be a setback for the EU's rapidly growing non-alcoholic drinks industry.
This is not the initial instance European courts have weighed in on consumable product labeling disputes. As an illustration, in the year 2018, the ECJ determined that the makers of KitKat were not permitted to trademark its distinctive four-fingered design.
Similarly, the year before, the judiciary decided that only items derived from animals could employ terms like milk, dairy spread, cream, and yogurt.
Upcoming Food Labeling Regulations
Meanwhile, the European parliament is seeking to strengthen product description rules more strictly. Last month, it moved to outlaw the use of words such as 'burger' and 'link' for vegan products.
This law is currently under discussion with EU member states, which could yet preserve plant-based patties and tofu steaks. However, currently, an non-alcoholic gin and tonic is, formally, not an option within the European Union.