Bahrain is preparing to claim before the Britain's highest judicial body that it possesses state immunity from accusations that it deployed spyware on the devices of two dissidents during their stay in London.
Legal Battle Context
The Gulf country has been denied its sovereign immunity claim in the lower court and appellate court. Taking the matter to the supreme court highlights the significance of this matter for the country's global standing.
Should Bahrain succeed, the ruling could have wider implications for how authoritarian states employ surveillance technology to monitor and possibly target political dissidents residing in the UK.
Central Issue of Supreme Court Hearing
The legal proceedings, scheduled to begin this Wednesday, will concentrate on whether the two individuals have the standing to claim damages despite Bahrain's immunity claim, rather than addressing whether damages are applicable.
Claims and Proof
Dr Saeed Shehabi and Moosa Mohammed claim the Bahraini government used German-made FinFisher spyware to compromise their computers while they were living in London, causing psychological harm. The court of appeal last October supported a high court ruling that the State Immunity Act 1978 does not provide Bahrain sovereign immunity against their claims.
Section 5 of the act states that a state does not have immunity from legal actions for personal injury resulting from an act or omission that took place in the UK.
The decision will also provide clarity regarding additional spyware claims being handled by legal teams on behalf of affected individuals.
Software Capabilities
Legal representatives stated that "FinSpy software can collect vast amounts of data from infected devices, including recording all keyboard inputs, voice calls, messages, electronic mail, scheduling information, real-time chats, contacts lists, internet activity, photos, databases, documents and recordings. It allows capture of real-time sound from the device's microphone and visual recording device."
Legal Interpretation
The appellate court found that remote manipulation, from abroad, of a electronic device situated in the United Kingdom constituted an action within the British territory. Even if the hacking took place overseas, the consequence was that the territorial sovereignty of the UK had suffered interference.
A overseas nation does not have protection for psychological harm caused by an act in the United Kingdom, even if certain acts take place overseas. The court also ruled that "personal injury" as defined in the state immunity act encompassed independent psychological damage.
Bahrain's Stance
The appellate decision noted that Bahrain denied the accusers' claims of compromising the activists' devices with surveillance software, but the initial court justice "determined, on the basis of specialist testimony, that the plaintiffs had discharged the responsibility upon them of demonstrating on the preponderance of evidence that their computers were infected by spyware by Bahrain's servants or agents."
Plaintiffs' Statements
Shehabi, a co-founder of the opposition group al-Wefaq, welcomed with the legal proceedings, saying: "I'm satisfied with the outcome so far of the legal proceedings regarding the hacking of my computer. It sends a strong signal to overseas authorities who target their non-violent critics with multiple methods including violating their personal affairs and equipment."
Mohammed, who fled Bahrain in 2006 after experiencing frequent detention within the country, stated: "Our journey has now reached the supreme judicial body in the land. I have a duty to reveal what I experienced when I believe Bahrain compromised my computer. The effect has been devastating – especially for those who placed their trust in me, and for my friends and family."
"Repressive governments like Bahrain must be brought to justice for destroying our lives. They cannot be allowed to use state protection to pursue their transnational repression on British soil."
The two individuals have had their nationality revoked.
Legal Perspective
A senior legal representative stated: "This case present essential issues about accountability for the use of invasive monitoring systems against political activists and human rights defenders. Our represented individuals, and numerous additional people we represent, have waited a long time for resolution on these matters."